Donald Trump had lost Pennsylvania. A federal judge had rejected his campaign's lawsuit. Joe Biden was ahead by more than 70,000 votes.
But Trump was not ready to accept the result.
On November 22, 2020, the Trump campaign filed an appeal with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, continuing its effort to challenge Pennsylvania's presidential election outcome.
The filing came just one day after a federal judge dismissed the campaign's lawsuit, finding that its arguments and evidence could not justify the extraordinary relief it sought.
Rather than accept the defeat, Trump's legal team was seeking another opportunity to pursue a case that could interfere with certification of Biden's victory.
A Crushing Defeat in Federal Court
On November 21, U.S. District Judge Matthew Brann dismissed the Trump campaign's lawsuit against Pennsylvania election officials.
The campaign had challenged differences in how counties handled mail-in ballots, particularly opportunities for voters to correct technical defects.
Trump's attorneys argued that these practices violated constitutional protections.
But the court found the campaign had failed to establish a legally sufficient basis for its requested remedy.
The lawsuit sought relief that could prevent Pennsylvania from certifying election results involving millions of voters.
Brann concluded that the campaign's allegations and legal arguments did not come close to justifying such an outcome.
The dismissal was another setback in Trump's nationwide effort to contest the presidential election.
Trump Takes the Fight to an Appeals Court
On November 22, Trump's lawyers filed a notice of appeal and requested expedited review.
The appeal focused on a narrower procedural question: whether the district court should have permitted the campaign to file a second amended complaint.
The campaign wanted another opportunity to present its allegations and seek judicial intervention in Pennsylvania's election results.
In its emergency filing, Trump's lawyers indicated they could pursue an order preventing certification or potentially decertifying results if certification had already occurred.
The distinction mattered.
The campaign was not merely requesting a routine recount.
It was pursuing litigation that, if successful, could have disrupted the state's recognition of Biden's victory.
More Than 70,000 Votes Behind
By November 22, Biden's lead in Pennsylvania exceeded 70,000 votes.
The margin presented a substantial obstacle to Trump's attempt to change the outcome.
Even if the campaign established problems with certain ballot procedures, that would not automatically justify invalidating votes or reversing the election.
Courts require specific legal claims, supporting evidence, and remedies appropriate to the violations established.
Trump's campaign had not demonstrated that the alleged irregularities could justify the sweeping relief it sought.
Nevertheless, the president continued publicly alleging that the election had been stolen.
Those allegations were not substantiated by the evidence presented in the Pennsylvania lawsuit.
The Strategy Extended Beyond Pennsylvania
The Pennsylvania appeal was part of a broader effort to challenge Biden's victories in several battleground states.
Trump and his allies were also contesting results in Michigan, Georgia, Wisconsin, Arizona, and Nevada.
On November 20, Trump had met with Republican legislative leaders from Michigan at the White House.
The lawmakers subsequently stated that they had received no information warranting a change to their state's election outcome.
Georgia had already completed a statewide hand audit confirming Biden's victory.
Yet Trump continued disputing the results.
The Pennsylvania appeal demonstrated that his campaign was still seeking legal avenues to interfere with an election outcome that voters and election officials had established.
Republican Resistance Begins to Grow
Trump's continuing legal challenges were also creating disagreements within his own party.
On November 21, Pennsylvania Republican Senator Pat Toomey congratulated Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris.
Toomey stated that Trump had exhausted his plausible legal options in Pennsylvania and urged the president to begin cooperating with the transition.
Other Republicans continued supporting Trump's right to pursue legal challenges.
But the growing number of courtroom setbacks made the campaign's effort increasingly difficult to sustain.
The Appeal Would Fail Too
The Third Circuit agreed to consider the appeal on an expedited schedule.
On November 27, a three-judge panel rejected the campaign's arguments and affirmed the lower court's decision.
The opinion was written by Judge Stephanos Bibas, a Trump appointee.
The court emphasized that allegations of unfairness required specific claims and supporting proof.
The judges found the campaign had not provided a sufficient basis for overturning the district court's decision or granting the extraordinary election-related relief it sought.
Pennsylvania's certified results remained intact.
A President Still Fighting the Voters' Decision
November 22, 2020, marked another step in Trump's refusal to accept his electoral defeat.
The previous day, a federal judge had rejected his Pennsylvania lawsuit.
Rather than move toward conceding, his campaign immediately appealed and sought another opportunity to challenge the outcome.
Trump had the legal right to appeal an adverse court ruling.
But the relief his campaign continued pursuing went far beyond asking officials to review a small number of disputed ballots.
It sought a path toward blocking or undoing certification of a state Biden had won by tens of thousands of votes.
The appeal ultimately failed.
But the episode became part of the documented history of Trump's post-election campaign to reverse the results of the 2020 presidential election.
On November 22, the legal battle continued even as the evidence necessary to justify changing Pennsylvania's result remained absent.
