On December 2, 2020, President Donald Trump filed a federal lawsuit challenging Wisconsin's certified presidential election results, seeking judicial intervention that could overturn Joe Biden's victory in the state.

The lawsuit targeted the Wisconsin Elections Commission, Governor Tony Evers, and numerous state and local election officials.

Trump alleged that election administrators had improperly changed voting procedures during the COVID-19 pandemic, violating the constitutional authority of Wisconsin's legislature.

The legal challenge came two days after Wisconsin officially certified Biden's victory by approximately 20,600 votes.

Trump Challenges Wisconsin's Election Procedures

Rather than establishing widespread voter fraud, Trump's lawsuit focused primarily on how Wisconsin officials administered the election.

His attorneys argued that guidance issued by the Wisconsin Elections Commission departed from state election laws.

The challenged procedures involved absentee voting, election administration, and accommodations made during the pandemic.

Trump maintained that these changes violated the Constitution's Electors Clause, which gives state legislatures authority over the manner of selecting presidential electors.

His lawsuit claimed that the alleged violations potentially affected more than 50,000 ballots.

That figure exceeded Biden's certified margin of victory.

Seeking to Set Aside the Election

The lawsuit requested extraordinary relief.

Trump wanted the federal court to declare that election officials had violated constitutional requirements and allow Wisconsin's legislature to consider remedies concerning the state's presidential electors.

Such intervention could have undermined the certified election results and potentially deprived Biden of Wisconsin's ten electoral votes.

The lawsuit formed part of a broader legal campaign challenging results in states Trump had lost.

Across several battleground states, Trump and his allies pursued litigation involving absentee ballots, election procedures, and allegations of misconduct.

A Trump-Appointed Judge Hears the Case

The Wisconsin lawsuit was assigned to U.S. District Judge Brett Ludwig, whom Trump had appointed to the federal bench earlier that year.

On December 12, Ludwig dismissed the lawsuit with prejudice after considering the evidence and legal arguments.

The judge concluded that Wisconsin officials had conducted the election in accordance with the system established by the state legislature.

He found that Trump had failed to demonstrate a constitutional violation sufficient to justify overturning the results.

The dismissal with prejudice meant the claims could not simply be refiled in the same court.

The Court Rejects Trump's Arguments

Ludwig described the lawsuit as extraordinary because a sitting president was asking a federal court to set aside the results of a statewide popular election.

The judge determined that Trump's objections concerned the implementation of election procedures rather than an unconstitutional change in how Wisconsin selected its electors.

The court found no substantial departure from the legislature's established election system.

Ludwig also observed that Trump could have raised objections to the challenged procedures before Election Day rather than waiting until after losing.

The decision rejected Trump's request to interfere with Wisconsin's certified results.

Appeals Bring No Relief

Trump appealed the ruling to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals.

On December 24, 2020, the appeals court affirmed the dismissal, concluding that his constitutional arguments lacked merit.

Trump subsequently sought Supreme Court review.

On March 8, 2021, the Supreme Court declined to hear the case.

Wisconsin's election results remained unchanged.

A Presidential Election Challenged in Federal Court

The December 2 lawsuit illustrated the extent of Trump's efforts to contest his 2020 defeat through the courts.

His administration had already received an assessment from Attorney General William Barr that federal investigators had not discovered fraud sufficient to change the election outcome.

Nevertheless, Trump continued pursuing legal challenges that could have altered certified results.

The Wisconsin case ultimately failed before a judge Trump had appointed, and the rejection was upheld on appeal.

It remains an important part of the historical record of the legal efforts to overturn the 2020 presidential election.