An Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent who fatally shot a Colombian father in Maine had previously expressed vicious hostility toward Colombian immigrants, according to emails released by his own sister.

The revelations raise serious questions about how David Brouillette, 38, was allowed to carry a federal badge and firearm despite a troubling history that included allegations of domestic abuse, threatening behavior, and warnings from his own family.

His Own Sister Exposed Him

In 2021, Brouillette sent a series of hostile emails attacking his sister Elizabeth Emen over her relationship with a Colombian-born graduate student who was living legally in the United States.

Brouillette demanded that the man return to his country, disparaged his Colombian heritage, and claimed his ancestry made him unworthy of American freedoms.

His sister subsequently provided the emails to The New York Times.

Emen explained that her brother's hostility had nothing to do with her partner's actual immigration status. She believed it was motivated by racial prejudice.

The messages also included an angry declaration that his sister was effectively dead to him.

These weren't anonymous internet comments. They were messages sent directly to family members, years before Brouillette became an ICE agent.

A Father Killed in Front of His Family

On July 13, 2026, Brouillette fatally shot 25-year-old Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero during an attempted immigration enforcement stop in Biddeford, Maine.

Guerrero, a Colombian national authorized to work in the United States, was driving to work when ICE agents confronted him.

He was shot four times in front of his wife and their three-year-old daughter.

The Department of Homeland Security initially suggested Guerrero had entered the country illegally, a claim it later withdrew.

Attorneys representing his family say Guerrero wasn't even the target of the immigration investigation.

DHS maintains that officers feared for public safety when Guerrero allegedly attempted to flee. The circumstances surrounding the shooting remain under investigation.

His Family Had Already Sounded the Alarm

The disturbing emails weren't the only warning signs.

Previous reporting by the Associated Press documented allegations of abusive and threatening behavior involving Brouillette's former spouses and family members.

A judge had issued a protection order involving his daughter in 2021.

His mother, Susan Bedard, offered an extraordinary warning about her own son, saying he was dangerous and should not possess weapons.

Yet Brouillette ultimately joined ICE during the Trump administration's aggressive expansion of immigration enforcement.

That raises an unavoidable question:

Who reviewed this man's background before handing him a gun and federal law-enforcement authority?

The Bigger Problem at ICE

The Trump administration has prioritized expanding immigration enforcement and rapidly increasing ICE staffing.

But the allegations surrounding Brouillette illustrate the potential consequences when recruitment targets outpace adequate screening and oversight.

His reported hostility toward Colombians does not, by itself, establish the motive behind Guerrero's killing. Investigators must determine whether the shooting was legally justified.

Nevertheless, the documented warning signs deserve scrutiny.

A 25-year-old father is dead. His wife and young daughter witnessed his final moments.

And the federal government must explain how an agent with such serious allegations in his background was entrusted with the authority to use deadly force.

The warning signs were there. The question is why nobody stopped him.